To London, from New York... or should I say from Paris
The proposed final phases of New York’s internationally
renown High Line is for a secluded bowl shaped structure. This further
development will increase the High Line from West 30th Street to West 34th
Street, and the extension is rightfully gratified so that it can continue to
offer an area of tranquillity in such a busy city.
The High Line’s extension will provide further rare and valuable calmness,
peacefulness and serenity to the pedestrians of New York. The proposed “Green
Bowl” developed by James Corner Field Operations and Diller Scofidio + Renfro,
immerses the people into a completely natural environment as most of Manhattan’s
skyline will be blocked out by the surrounding wildlife. This offers people a
place that they can relax and escape from the normal hustle and bustle of the
city’s streets.
Image by James Corner Field Operations and Diller Scofidio + Renfro, courtesy
of Designboom.
Yes, New York does have plenty of parks, between 1,700 and 1,800 according to
The New York City Department of Parks & Recreation, but they are all level
and often surrounded by streets full of traffic. What makes the High Line so
special is that it allows people to escape from this and either relax or walk
to work through a wildlife area. This is why the development has such a big
interest from cities all around the world. Most notable and exciting for me is
the proposed “Garden Bridge” by Thomas Heatherwick which would feature a park
over the River Thames in London.
The Garden Bridge is at the beginning of its planning and aims to offer pedestrians
a unique and unparalleled view of London from the river Thames. The combination of Thomas Heatherwick’s design
team and Joanna Lumley came up with this pedestrian only, park bridge and needs
a lot of planning work for it to succeed. In spite of this, I do believe it can
succeed and the reasons for the bridge are vast, the only limitation is whether
it is possible. There is no doubt however, that the High Line was their source
of inspiration as it aims to offer people a calm, chilled way of crossing the
river.


Photos from Dezeen.
You could say that New York’s High Line is revolutionary and pioneering as it
has been the catalyst for similar projects being designed in cities across the
world. However, to an extent that would be a false claim as many of you may not
know that the High Line was inspired by Paris’ Promenade Plantée.
Completed in 1993, the Promenade Plantée or Coulée Vert is an elevated park
developed on top of an old and unused railway line. This sounds very similar to
the High Line, which poses the question how come the Promenade Plantée did not
kick start equivalent projects in other cities like the High Line has? Maybe the
situation of the Coulée Vert is not in the busy part of Paris, maybe the city
is not as busy as New York or maybe it is the different culture of Parisians
that cause the park to be less of an attraction. Whatever the reason may be,
the Promenade Plantée did not grab the environmental departments of the world’s
cities.
Images courtesy of Eurotrips.
This brings me back to my previous point that you could claim New York’s High
Line is pioneering in the attraction of green areas in cities. The Promenade
Plantée may have inspired the development but the High Line is inspiring the
modern developments across the globe. The development scheme has prompted
similar parks already such as; the Bloomingdale Trail (Chicago, USA), the
Reading Viaduct (Philadelphia, USA) and Maidashi
Ryokuchi (Fukuoka, Japan). As well as prompting extremely exciting, future
developments such as the Garden Bridge (London, UK) and the very interesting
Low Line (Manhattan, New York).
The High Line is a fantastic development that is a continuous success. It has
provided the people of New York a relaxed, fun and therapeutic way to travel
around the city. There is no doubt that the success of this scheme has
prompting similar redevelopment projects in cities around the United States and
across the world. However, we all need to remember and admire the Promenade
Plantée for its innovative and ingenious project that is shaping the future
landscapes of our cities.
By Tim Spears